Discover tools and strategies for supporting English as a Second Language (ESL) and English Language Learners (ELL). Explore resources to enhance language learning.
What if you could use an acronym to spur student thinking to move beyond surface learning to transfer learning? Teachers are student learning watchers. You are eager to see the lightbulb go off in students’ heads. As a teacher, I feel like person waiting for the chick in the egg break out of its shell. I want to help without taking away the productive struggle. What if we could give students the tools they need to move from simple to complex thinking? What if we could make this process a little more obvious for students? That’s the purpose of the PRISM Framework (see the handy infographic below). Be sure to read part two of this series for science educators.
Note: This blog entry was inspired by Geoff Petty’s explanation of the SOLO Taxonomy in his book, Evidence-Based Teaching. As I read his explanation of the SOLO Taxonomy, I started to wonder, could a model of the SOLO Taxonomy be constructed to aid my own progress from simple to complex levels? From there, it wasn’t long to begin exploring ideas and finding ways to represent them. I relied on Perplexity AI, ChatGPT, and Napkin AI as thought partners and artifact developers. Let me know what you think in the comments.
Revisiting the SOLO Taxonomy
The Structure of the Observed Learning Outcome (SOLO) Taxonomy is designed to reflect the structure of students’ work. This makes it a valuable tool, especially with AI-generated work, since it enables us to see how students progress through the levels of SOLO.
The SOLO Taxonomy describes how student learning moves from simple to complex understanding For example, learning to see individual patterns and ideas and how they connect to others reflects two SOLO levels. Those levels are Unistructural and Multistructural. It involves having questions about surface level identification of a pattern to deeper pattern recognition.
The SOLO Taxonomy focuses on describing how students see relationships between what they know and what they are learning. Seeing how big ideas fit together, how they can be connected ties into the deeper conceptual understanding and relationships our brains are making. When information doesn’t quite fit our understanding, we have to find an alternate perspective or make a hypothesis that fits the data we have.
Facilitating this with students can be difficult. That’s where PRISM comes in.
Introducing PRISM
Think of PRISM as a structured framework. It guides students as they engage in critical thinking and analysis. The goal for students is to move from Unistructural to Relational. PRISM asks questions that cue learners to shift from basic pattern recognition to sophisticated reasoning.
Like a prism that separates light into its component colors, this framework breaks down complex thinking into five key elements: Patterns, Reasoning, Ideas, Situation, and Methods. Each element builds upon the previous one, helping students progress from simple identification of facts through to deeper analysis and testing of hypotheses.
The PRISM Framework’s Key Features
- Starts with simple pattern recognition
- Builds through logical reasoning steps
- Encourages multiple perspectives
- Examines broader contexts
- Tests and validates understanding
Let’s take a closer look at the elements of the PRISM Framework.
PRISM Framework Questions
What makes PRISM powerful is its flexibility and scalability. You can apply it to simple tasks or complex problems. All the while, you are moving forward to enhanced analytical skills.
PRISM Element | Core Question | Deep Questions |
---|---|---|
P – Patterns | What patterns do you see? | • What big ideas keep showing up? • How do these patterns work in different places? • What general patterns help us understand better? |
R – Reasoning | How do things fit together? | • How do pieces connect to tell the whole story? • What makes sense when you look at everything? • How do different parts work together? |
I – Ideas | What different ideas can we mix? | • What happens when we try new ways of thinking? • What other ideas should we explore? • How do different viewpoints help us understand? |
S – Situation | What’s the bigger picture? | • How does this connect to other things? • What else affects what’s happening? • What’s important beyond what we first see? |
M – Methods | How can we check our answers? | • What other ways could explain this? • How do we know which answer is right? • What different ways can we solve this? |
Now that you have had a chance to review this, let’s put PRISM through its paces with a real-life example. Two are provided but you could come up with quite a bit more for your state standards.
Example #1: Fifth Grade Writing
As a fifth and sixth grade classroom teacher, my students in writing workshop would have benefited from the PRISM Framework. It’s a bit of metacognition that can help young authors step outside the piece they are writing. Consider the following:
- Patterns: Students identify narrative structure patterns in mentor texts and their own writing
- Reasoning: Students connect their narrative events logically with transition words and temporal sequences
- Ideas: Students combine multiple perspectives and details to enhance their story
- Situation: Students expand their narrative beyond just events to include broader themes
- Methods: Students test different writing techniques like dialogue and descriptive language
For each stage in PRISM, students are making progress from simple descriptions to deeper connections. Here’s what that might look like:
- Patterns. “I notice all good stories about sports have exciting moments and feelings. In my story, I’ll include how nervous I felt before the game and how excited I was when I scored my first goal.”
- Reasoning. “My story needs to flow in order. First, I’ll write about arriving at the field, then warming up with my team, next playing the game, and finally celebrating after.”
- Ideas. “I can tell my story from different angles – how I felt, what my teammates said, what the crowd was doing, and what my coach taught me that day.”
- Situation. “This wasn’t just about playing soccer – it was about learning to be brave, working with my team, and discovering that practice pays off. These bigger ideas make my story more interesting.”
- Methods. “I can make my story better by trying different ways to tell it. Maybe I’ll add dialogue like ‘Great shot!’ from my coach, or describe the sound of cleats on grass and the smell of fresh-cut field.”
But writing isn’t the only content area you could try this out in.
Example #2: Fifth Grade Science
It’s appropriate that students have to “demonstrate that light travels in a straight line until it strikes an object or travels through one medium to another” (TEKS 5.6C). Let’s apply PRISM to science lesson on how light behaves.
PRISM Element | Core Question | Example with Light & Prisms Unit |
---|---|---|
P – Patterns | What patterns do you see? | “I notice that light always travels in straight lines until it hits something, and when it goes through a prism it always makes the same rainbow colors in the same order” |
R – Reasoning | How do things fit together? | “When sunlight enters a prism, different colors bend different amounts, which is why we see them spread out in a rainbow pattern” |
I – Ideas | What different ideas can we mix? | “We can combine different tools like CDs, crystals, and prisms to make different types of rainbows and explore how light bends in different materials” |
S – Situation | What’s the bigger picture? | “Light is a form of energy that helps us see, and understanding how it bends and splits helps us use it in important tools like telescopes and eyeglasses” |
M – Methods | How can we check our answers? | “We can test how light behaves by using different materials like water bowls, prisms, and flashlights to see if our ideas about light are correct” |
Notice the transition from simple observations in Patterns element of the framework to deeper scientific understanding. Now that you’ve seen it in action, let’s take a look at some scaffolding for students engaged in using PRISM.
PRISM Sentence Stems
Sentence stems assist students in putting together sentences they might not be able to alone. These incomplete sentences support students as they engage in discussions and writing tasks. at their grade level. What’s more, they may promote critical thinking and make connections, see relationships between concepts.
Here are a few sentence stems for PRISM elements to get your students started:
PRISM Element | Core Question | Deep Questions | Sentence Stems |
---|---|---|---|
P – Patterns | What patterns do you see? | • What big ideas keep showing up? • How do these patterns work in different places? • What general patterns help us understand better? | • “Here, I noticed that…” • “The pattern I see is…” • “This reminds me of…” |
R – Reasoning | How do things fit together? | • How do pieces connect to tell the whole story? • What makes sense when you look at everything? • How do different parts work together? | • “This connects to… because…” • “The reason for this is…” • “One thing that makes sense is…” |
I – Ideas | What different ideas can we mix? | • What happens when we try new ways of thinking? • What other ideas should we explore? • How do different viewpoints help us understand? | • “Another way to think about this is…” • “I have a different viewpoint…” • “To add to that idea…” |
S – Situation | What’s the bigger picture? | • How does this connect to other things? • What else affects what’s happening? • What’s important beyond what we first see? | • “The bigger picture shows…” • “Beyond what we see here…” • “This connects to other things by…” |
M – Methods | How can we check our answers? | • What other ways could explain this? • How do we know which answer is right? • What different ways can we solve this? | • “We can test this by…” • “One way to check this is…” • “Another approach would be…” |
Here’s what those sentence stems might look like with the science example above:
Patterns
“Here, I noticed that the light beam always bends the same way when it passes through the prism.”
“The pattern I see is that white light splits into the same rainbow colors every time.”
“This reminds me of how rainbows form in the sky after it rains.”
Reasoning
- “This connects to refraction because the light waves change speed when they enter the prism.”
- “The reason for this is that different colors of light bend at different angles.”
- “One thing that makes sense is how the colors always appear in the same order – red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo, violet.”
Ideas
- “Another way to think about this is like light waves surfing through different materials.”
- “I have a different viewpoint about why the colors spread out.”
- “To add to that idea, we could try using different shaped prisms.”
Situation
- “The bigger picture shows how light energy behaves in our world.”
- “Beyond what we see here in class, prisms are used in real tools like telescopes.”
- “This connects to other things by showing how light helps us see colors everywhere.”
Methods
- “We can test this by using different materials like water and glass.”
- “One way to check this is to change the angle of the light beam.”
- “Another approach would be to try different light sources.”
Next Steps
Ready to embrace PRISM in your classroom? Here are some steps you can take:
- Start small. Begin with simple introduction of PRISM elements.
- Integrate gradually. Build PRISM elements into your lesson plan over time, increasing in complexity.
- Encourage reflection. Use the sentence stems to promote thoughtful discussions and writing.
- Assess progress. Monitor student growth in critical thinking using a PRISM-aligned rubric.
Introducing PRISM To Your Colleagues
Ready to introduce PRISM to your colleagues? Use this handy presentation to get started. And, please find the infographic below: